At the home of Jane Withersteen Little Fay was climbing Lassiter's knee.
"Does oo love me?" she asked.
Lassiter, who was as serious with Fay as he was gentle and loving, assured
her in earnest and elaborate speech that he was her devoted subject. Fay
looked thoughtful and appeared to be debating the duplicity of men or
searching for a supreme test to prove this cavalier.
"Does oo love my new mower?" she asked, with bewildering suddenness.
Jane Withersteen laughed, and for the first time in many a day she felt a
stir of her pulse and warmth in her cheek.
It was a still drowsy summer of afternoon, and the three were sitting in
the shade of the wooded knoll that faced the sage-slope Little Fay's brief
spell of unhappy longing for her mother—the childish, mystic gloom—had
passed, and now where Fay was there were prattle and laughter and glee.
She had emerged from sorrow to be the incarnation of joy and loveliness.
She had grown supernaturally sweet and beautiful. For Jane Withersteen the
child was an answer to prayer, a blessing, a possession infinitely more
precious than all she had lost. For Lassiter, Jane divined that little Fay
had become a religion.
"Does oo love my new mower?" repeated Fay.
Lassiter's answer to this was a modest and sincere affirmative.
"Why don't oo marry my new mower an' be my favver?"
Of the thousands of questions put by little Fay to Lassiter this was the
first he had been unable to answer.
"Fay—Fay, don't ask questions like that," said Jane.
"Because," replied Jane. And she found it strangely embarrassing to meet
the child's gaze. It seemed to her that Fay's violet eyes looked through
her with piercing wisdom.
"Oo love him, don't oo?"
"Dear child—run and play," said Jane, "but don't go too far. Don't
go from this little hill."
Fay pranced off wildly, joyous over freedom that had not been granted her
"Jane, why are children more sincere than grown-up persons?" asked
"I reckon so. Little Fay there—she sees things as they appear on the
face. An Indian does that. So does a dog. An' an Indian an' a dog are most
of the time right in what they see. Mebbe a child is always right."
"Well, what does Fay see?" asked Jane.
"I reckon you know. I wonder what goes on in Fay's mind when she sees part
of the truth with the wise eyes of a child, an' wantin' to know more,
meets with strange falseness from you? Wait! You are false in a way,
though you're the best woman I ever knew. What I want to say is this. Fay
has taken you're pretendin' to—to care for me for the thing it looks
on the face. An' her little formin' mind asks questions. An' the answers
she gets are different from the looks of things. So she'll grow up
gradually takin' on that falseness, an' be like the rest of the women, an'
men, too. An' the truth of this falseness to life is proved by your
appearin' to love me when you don't. Things aren't what they seem."
"Lassiter, you're right. A child should be told the absolute truth. But—is
that possible? I haven't been able to do it, and all my life I've loved
the truth, and I've prided myself upon being truthful. Maybe that was only
egotism. I'm learning much, my friend. Some of those blinding scales have
fallen from my eyes. And—and as to caring for you, I think I care a
great deal. How much, how little, I couldn't say. My heart is almost
broken. Lassiter. So now is not a good time to judge of affection. I can
still play and be merry with Fay. I can still dream. But when I attempt
serious thought I'm dazed. I don't think. I don't care any more. I don't
pray!... Think of that, my friend! But in spite of my numb feeling I
believe I'll rise out of all this dark agony a better woman, with greater
love of man and God. I'm on the rack now; I'm senseless to all but pain,
and growing dead to that. Sooner or later I shall rise out of this stupor.
I'm waiting the hour."
"It'll soon come, Jane," replied Lassiter, soberly. "Then I'm afraid for
you. Years are terrible things, an' for years you've been bound. Habit of
years is strong as life itself. Somehow, though, I believe as you—that
you'll come out of it all a finer woman. I'm waitin', too. An' I'm
wonderin'—I reckon, Jane, that marriage between us is out of all
"Lassiter!... My dear friend!... It's impossible for us to marry!"
"Why—as Fay says?" inquired Lassiter, with gentle persistence.
"Why! I never thought why. But it's not possible. I am Jane, daughter of
Withersteen. My father would rise out of his grave. I'm of Mormon birth.
I'm being broken. But I'm still a Mormon woman. And you—you are
"Mebbe I'm not so much Lassiter as I used to be."
"What was it you said? Habit of years is strong as life itself! You can't
change the one habit—the purpose of your life. For you still pack
those black guns! You still nurse your passion for blood."
A smile, like a shadow, flickered across his face.
"Lassiter, I lied to you. But I beg of you—don't you lie to me. I've
great respect for you. I believe you're softened toward most, perhaps all,
my people except—But when I speak of your purpose, your hate, your
guns, I have only him in mind. I don't believe you've changed."
For answer he unbuckled the heavy cartridge-belt, and laid it with the
heavy, swing gun-sheaths in her lap.
"Lassiter!" Jane whispered, as she gazed from him to the black, cold guns.
Without them he appeared shorn of strength, defenseless, a smaller man.
Was she Delilah? Swiftly, conscious of only one motive—refusal to
see this man called craven by his enemies—she rose, and with
blundering fingers buckled the belt round his waist where it belonged.
"Lassiter, I am a coward."
"Come with me out of Utah—where I can put away my guns an' be a
man," he said. "I reckon I'll prove it to you then! Come! You've got Black
Star back, an' Night an' Bells. Let's take the racers an' little Fay, en'
race out of Utah. The hosses an' the child are all you have left. Come!"
"No, no, Lassiter. I'll never leave Utah. What would I do in the world
with my broken fortunes and my broken heart? Ill never leave these purple
slopes I love so well."
"I reckon I ought to 've knowed that. Presently you'll be livin' down here
in a hovel, en' presently Jane Withersteen will be a memory. I only wanted
to have a chance to show you how a man—any man—can be better
'n he was. If we left Utah I could prove—I reckon I could prove this
thing you call love. It's strange, an' hell an' heaven at once, Jane
Withersteen. 'Pears to me that you've thrown away your big heart on love—love
of religion an' duty an' churchmen, an' riders an' poor families an' poor
children! Yet you can't see what love is—how it changes a person!...
Listen, an' in tellin' you Milly Erne's story I'll show you how love
"Milly an' me was children when our family moved from Missouri to Texas,
an' we growed up in Texas ways same as if we'd been born there. We had
been poor, an' there we prospered. In time the little village where we
went became a town, an' strangers an' new families kept movin' in. Milly
was the belle them days. I can see her now, a little girl no bigger 'n a
bird, an' as pretty. She had the finest eyes, dark blue-black when she was
excited, an' beautiful all the time. You remember Milly's eyes! An' she
had light-brown hair with streaks of gold, an' a mouth that every feller
wanted to kiss.
"An' about the time Milly was the prettiest an' the sweetest, along came a
young minister who began to ride some of a race with the other fellers for
Milly. An' he won. Milly had always been strong on religion, an' when she
met Frank Erne she went in heart an' soul for the salvation of souls. Fact
was, Milly, through study of the Bible an' attendin' church an' revivals,
went a little out of her head. It didn't worry the old folks none, an' the
only worry to me was Milly's everlastin' prayin' an' workin' to save my
soul. She never converted me, but we was the best of comrades, an' I
reckon no brother an' sister ever loved each other better. Well, Frank
Erne an me hit up a great friendship. He was a strappin' feller, good to
look at, an' had the most pleasin' ways. His religion never bothered me,
for he could hunt an' fish an' ride an' be a good feller. After buffalo
once, he come pretty near to savin' my life. We got to be thick as
brothers, an' he was the only man I ever seen who I thought was good
enough for Milly. An' the day they were married I got drunk for the only
time in my life.
"Soon after that I left home—it seems Milly was the only one who
could keep me home—an' I went to the bad, as to prosperin' I saw
some pretty hard life in the Pan Handle, an' then I went North. In them
days Kansas an' Nebraska was as bad, come to think of it, as these days
right here on the border of Utah. I got to be pretty handy with guns. An'
there wasn't many riders as could beat me ridin'. An' I can say all
modest-like that I never seen the white man who could track a hoss or a
steer or a man with me. Afore I knowed it two years slipped by, an' all at
once I got homesick, en' purled a bridle south.
"Things at home had changed. I never got over that homecomin'. Mother was
dead an' in her grave. Father was a silent, broken man, killed already on
his feet. Frank Erne was a ghost of his old self, through with workin',
through with preachin', almost through with livin', an' Milly was gone!...
It was a long time before I got the story. Father had no mind left, an'
Frank Erne was afraid to talk. So I had to pick up whet 'd happened from
"It 'pears that soon after I left home another preacher come to the little
town. An' he an' Frank become rivals. This feller was different from
Frank. He preached some other kind of religion, and he was quick an'
passionate, where Frank was slow an' mild. He went after people, women
specially. In looks he couldn't compare to Frank Erne, but he had power
over women. He had a voice, an' he talked an' talked an' preached an'
preached. Milly fell under his influence.. She became mightily interested
in his religion. Frank had patience with her, as was his way, an' let her
be as interested as she liked. All religions were devoted to one God, he
said, an' it wouldn't hurt Milly none to study a different point of view.
So the new preacher often called on Milly, an' sometimes in Frank's
absence. Frank was a cattle-man between Sundays.
"Along about this time an incident come off that I couldn't get much light
on. A stranger come to town, an' was seen with the preacher. This stranger
was a big man with an eye like blue ice, an' a beard of gold. He had
money, an' he 'peered a man of mystery, an' the town went to buzzin' when
he disappeared about the same time as a young woman known to be mightily
interested in the new preacher's religion. Then, presently, along comes a
man from somewheres in Illinois, en' he up an' spots this preacher as a
famous Mormon proselyter. That riled Frank Erne as nothin' ever before,
an' from rivals they come to be bitter enemies. An' it ended in Frank
goin' to the meetin'-house where Milly was listenin', en' before her en'
everybody else he called that preacher—called him, well, almost as
hard as Venters called Tull here sometime back. An' Frank followed up that
call with a hosswhippin', en' he drove the proselyter out of town.
"People noticed, so 'twas said, that Milly's sweet disposition changed.
Some said it was because she would soon become a mother, en' others said
she was pinin' after the new religion. An' there was women who said right
out that she was pinin' after the Mormon. Anyway, one mornin' Frank rode
in from one of his trips, to find Milly gone. He had no real near
neighbors—livin' a little out of town—but those who was
nearest said a wagon had gone by in the night, an' they though it stopped
at her door. Well, tracks always tell, an' there was the wagon tracks an'
hoss tracks an' man tracks. The news spread like wildfire that Milly had
run off from her husband. Everybody but Frank believed it an' wasn't slow
in tellin' why she run off. Mother had always hated that strange streak of
Milly's, takin' up with the new religion as she had, an' she believed
Milly ran off with the Mormon. That hastened mother's death, an' she died
unforgivin'. Father wasn't the kind to bow down under disgrace or
misfortune but he had surpassin' love for Milly, an' the loss of her broke
"From the minute I heard of Milly's disappearance I never believed she
went off of her own free will. I knew Milly, an' I knew she couldn't have
done that. I stayed at home awhile, tryin' to make Frank Erne talk. But if
he knowed anythin' then he wouldn't tell it. So I set out to find Milly.
An' I tried to get on the trail of that proselyter. I knew if I ever
struck a town he'd visited that I'd get a trail. I knew, too, that nothin'
short of hell would stop his proselytin'. An' I rode from town to town. I
had a blind faith that somethin' was guidin' me. An' as the weeks an'
months went by I growed into a strange sort of a man, I guess. Anyway,
people were afraid of me. Two years after that, way over in a corner of
Texas, I struck a town where my man had been. He'd jest left. People said
he came to that town without a woman. I back-trailed my man through
Arkansas an' Mississippi, an' the old trail got hot again in Texas. I
found the town where he first went after leavin' home. An' here I got
track of Milly. I found a cabin where she had given birth to her baby.
There was no way to tell whether she'd been kept a prisoner or not. The
feller who owned the place was a mean, silent sort of a skunk, an' as I
was leavin' I jest took a chance an' left my mark on him. Then I went home
"It was to find I hadn't any home, no more. Father had been dead a year.
Frank Erne still lived in the house where Milly had left him. I stayed
with him awhile, an' I grew old watchin' him. His farm had gone to weed,
his cattle had strayed or been rustled, his house weathered till it
wouldn't keep out rain nor wind. An' Frank set on the porch and whittled
sticks, an' day by day wasted away. There was times when he ranted about
like a crazy man, but mostly he was always sittin' an' starin' with eyes
that made a man curse. I figured Frank had a secret fear that I needed to
know. An' when I told him I'd trailed Milly for near three years an' had
got trace of her, an' saw where she'd had her baby, I thought he would
drop dead at my feet. An' when he'd come round more natural-like he begged
me to give up the trail. But he wouldn't explain. So I let him alone, an'
watched him day en' night.
"An' I found there was one thing still precious to him, an' it was a
little drawer where he kept his papers. This was in the room where he
slept. An' it 'peered he seldom slept. But after bein' patient I got the
contents of that drawer an' found two letters from Milly. One was a long
letter written a few months after her disappearance. She had been bound
an' gagged an' dragged away from her home by three men, an' she named them—Hurd,
Metzger, Slack. They was strangers to her. She was taken to the little
town where I found trace of her two years after. But she didn't send the
letter from that town. There she was penned in. 'Peared that the
proselytes, who had, of course, come on the scene, was not runnin' any
risks of losin' her. She went on to say that for a time she was out of her
head, an' when she got right again all that kept her alive was the baby.
It was a beautiful baby, she said, an' all she thought an' dreamed of was
somehow to get baby back to its father, an' then she'd thankfully lay down
and die. An' the letter ended abrupt, in the middle of a sentence, en' it
"The second letter was written more than two years after the first. It was
from Salt Lake City. It simply said that Milly had heard her brother was
on her trail. She asked Frank to tell her brother to give up the search
because if he didn't she would suffer in a way too horrible to tell. She
didn't beg. She just stated a fact an' made the simple request. An' she
ended that letter by sayin' she would soon leave Salt Lake City with the
man she had come to love, en' would never be heard of again.
"I recognized Milly's handwritin', an' I recognized her way of puttin'
things. But that second letter told me of some great change in her.
Ponderin' over it, I felt at last she'd either come to love that feller
an' his religion, or some terrible fear made her lie an' say so. I
couldn't be sure which. But, of course, I meant to find out. I'll say
here, if I'd known Mormons then as I do now I'd left Milly to her fate.
For mebbe she was right about what she'd suffer if I kept on her trail.
But I was young an' wild them days. First I went to the town where she'd
first been taken, an' I went to the place where she'd been kept. I got
that skunk who owned the place, an' took him out in the woods, an' made
him tell all he knowed. That wasn't much as to length, but it was pure
hell's-fire in substance. This time I left him some incapacitated for any
more skunk work short of hell. Then I hit the trail for Utah.
"That was fourteen years ago. I saw the incomin' of most of the Mormons.
It was a wild country an' a wild time. I rode from town to town, village
to village, ranch to ranch, camp to camp. I never stayed long in one
place. I never had but one idea. I never rested. Four years went by, an' I
knowed every trail in northern Utah. I kept on an' as time went by, an'
I'd begun to grow old in my search, I had firmer, blinder faith in
whatever was guidin' me. Once I read about a feller who sailed the seven
seas an' traveled the world, an' he had a story to tell, an' whenever he
seen the man to whom he must tell that story he knowed him on sight. I was
like that, only I had a question to ask. An' always I knew the man of whom
I must ask. So I never really lost the trail, though for many years it was
the dimmest trail ever followed by any man.
"Then come a change in my luck. Along in Central Utah I rounded up Hurd,
an' I whispered somethin' in his ear, an' watched his face, an' then
throwed a gun against his bowels. An' he died with his teeth so tight shut
I couldn't have pried them open with a knife. Slack an' Metzger that same
year both heard me whisper the same question, an' neither would they speak
a word when they lay dyin'. Long before I'd learned no man of this breed
or class—or God knows what—would give up any secrets! I had to
see in a man's fear of death the connections with Milly Erne's fate. An'
as the years passed at long intervals I would find such a man.
"So as I drifted on the long trail down into southern Utah my name
preceded me, an' I had to meet a people prepared for me, an' ready with
guns. They made me a gun-man. An' that suited me. In all this time signs
of the proselyter an' the giant with the blue-ice eyes an' the gold beard
seemed to fade dimmer out of the trail. Only twice in ten years did I find
a trace of that mysterious man who had visited the proselyter at my home
village. What he had to do with Milly's fate was beyond all hope for me to
learn, unless my guidin' spirit led me to him! As for the other man, I
knew, as sure as I breathed en' the stars shone en' the wind blew, that
I'd meet him some day.
"Eighteen years I've been on the trail. An' it led me to the last lonely
villages of the Utah border. Eighteen years!... I feel pretty old now. I
was only twenty when I hit that trail. Well, as I told you, back here a
ways a Gentile said Jane Withersteen could tell me about Milly Erne an'
show me her grave!"
The low voice ceased, and Lassiter slowly turned his sombrero round and
round, and appeared to be counting the silver ornaments on the band. Jane,
leaning toward him, sat as if petrified, listening intently, waiting to
hear more. She could have shrieked, but power of tongue and lips were
denied her. She saw only this sad, gray, passion-worn man, and she heard
only the faint rustling of the leaves.
"Well, I came to Cottonwoods," went on Lassiter, "an' you showed me
Milly's grave. An' though your teeth have been shut tighter 'n them of all
the dead men lyin' back along that trail, jest the same you told me the
secret I've lived these eighteen years to hear! Jane, I said you'd tell me
without ever me askin'. I didn't need to ask my question here. The day,
you remember, when that fat party throwed a gun on me in your court, an'—"
"Oh! Hush!" whispered Jane, blindly holding up her hands.
"I seen in your face that Dyer, now a bishop, was the proselyter who
ruined Milly Erne."
For an instant Jane Withersteen's brain was a whirling chaos and she
recovered to find herself grasping at Lassiter like one drowning. And as
if by a lightning stroke she sprang from her dull apathy into exquisite
"It's a lie! Lassiter! No, no!" she moaned. "I swear—you're wrong!"
"Stop! You'd perjure yourself! But I'll spare you that. You poor woman!
Still blind! Still faithful!... Listen. I know. Let that settle it. An' I
give up my purpose!"
"What is it—you say?"
"I give up my purpose. I've come to see an' feel differently. I can't help
poor Milly. An' I've outgrowed revenge. I've come to see I can be no judge
for men. I can't kill a man jest for hate. Hate ain't the same with me
since I loved you and little Fay."
"Lassiter! You mean you won't kill him?" Jane whispered.
"For my sake?"
"I reckon. I can't understand, but I'll respect your feelin's."
"Because you—oh, because you love me?... Eighteen years! You were
that terrible Lassiter! And now—because you love me?"
"That's it, Jane."
"Oh, you'll make me love you! How can I help but love you? My heart must
be stone. But—oh, Lassiter, wait, wait! Give me time. I'm not what I
was. Once it was so easy to love. Now it's easy to hate. Wait! My faith in
God—some God—still lives. By it I see happier times for you,
poor passion-swayed wanderer! For me—a miserable, broken woman. I
loved your sister Milly. I will love you. I can't have fallen so low—I
can't be so abandoned by God—that I've no love left to give you.
Wait! Let us forget Milly's sad life. Ah, I knew it as no one else on
earth! There's one thing I shall tell you—if you are at my
death-bed, but I can't speak now."
"I reckon I don't want to hear no more," said Lassiter.
Jane leaned against him, as if some pent-up force had rent its way out,
she fell into a paroxysm of weeping. Lassiter held her in silent sympathy.
By degrees she regained composure, and she was rising, sensible of being
relieved of a weighty burden, when a sudden start on Lassiter's part
"I heard hosses—hosses with muffled hoofs!" he said; and he got up
"Where's Fay?" asked Jane, hurriedly glancing round the shady knoll. The
bright-haired child, who had appeared to be close all the time, was not in
"Fay!" called Jane.
No answering shout of glee. No patter of flying feet. Jane saw Lassiter
"Fay—oh—Fay!" Jane almost screamed.
The leaves quivered and rustled; a lonesome cricket chirped in the grass,
a bee hummed by. The silence of the waning afternoon breathed hateful
portent. It terrified Jane. When had silence been so infernal?
"She's—only—strayed—out—of earshot," faltered
Jane, looking at Lassiter.
Pale, rigid as a statue, the rider stood, not in listening, searching
posture, but in one of doomed certainty. Suddenly he grasped Jane with an
iron hand, and, turning his face from her gaze, he strode with her from
"See—Fay played here last—a house of stones an' sticks.... An'
here's a corral of pebbles with leaves for hosses," said Lassiter,
stridently, and pointed to the ground. "Back an' forth she trailed
here.... See, she's buried somethin'—a dead grasshopper—there's
a tombstone... here she went, chasin' a lizard—see the tiny streaked
trail... she pulled bark off this cottonwood... look in the dust of the
path—the letters you taught her—she's drawn pictures of birds
en' hosses an' people.... Look, a cross! Oh, Jane, your cross!"
Lassiter dragged Jane on, and as if from a book read the meaning of little
Fay's trail. All the way down the knoll, through the shrubbery, round and
round a cottonwood, Fay's vagrant fancy left records of her sweet musings
and innocent play. Long had she lingered round a bird-nest to leave
therein the gaudy wing of a butterfly. Long had she played beside the
running stream sending adrift vessels freighted with pebbly cargo. Then
she had wandered through the deep grass, her tiny feet scarcely turning a
fragile blade, and she had dreamed beside some old faded flowers. Thus her
steps led her into the broad lane. The little dimpled imprints of her bare
feet showed clean-cut in the dust they went a little way down the lane;
and then, at a point where they stopped, the great tracks of a man led out
from the shrubbery and returned.